Cluster Development -
Requirement
for Holistic Sustainable Growth
Global
Perspective
What
comes to our mind when we think of a cluster? People working closely
with each other in small units, dimly lit setups, shabby lanes, polluted
landscape, ever growing dump yard, unhealthy workers doing their jobs in
an unsafe manner. Now let us take instances of the famous clusters
worldwide such as Silicon Valley cluster in California, the Information
Technology cluster of Bangalore in India, or the Australian and Chilean
wine clusters-the contrast can be easily noted in terms of productivity,
performance, working conditions and safety. The governments and the
development agencies have understood the importance of clusters and the
role they can play in transforming communities and economies together,
and are exploring ways to develop clusters to bridge the wide gap
between the two contrasting pictures highlighted above. In Europe
considerable progress has been made in the cluster approach. European
cluster observatory was launched in 2007 which provides information
about clusters, cluster initiatives and cluster policy in 32 European
countries. Europe also has a cluster excellence programme which works on
developing capacity of cluster managers, benchmarking best practices and
accrediting cluster organisations across European Union.
Indian Perspective
With a contribution of 40% to the country's
industrial output and 35% to direct exports, the Small-Scale Industry (SSI)
sector has achieved significant milestones for the industrial
development of India. Within the SSI sector, an important role is played
by the numerous clusters that have been in existence for decades and
sometimes even for centuries. According to a UNIDO survey of Indian SSI
clusters undertaken in 1996 (later updated in 1998), there are 350 SSI
clusters. Also, there are approximately 2000 rural and artisan based
clusters in India. It is estimated that these clusters contribute 60% of
the manufactured exports from India. The SSI clusters in India are
estimated to have a significantly high share in employment generation.1
Defining Cluster
A cluster is an agglomeration of small-scale
industrial units. There are many dimensions to the apparently routine
activities of a cluster. A cluster in itself is a thriving ecosystem-a
network of interconnected organisations. There are forward and backward
linkages, and then there are peripheral service providers, enhancing the
productivity and ensuring quality of production of a particular cluster,
such as designing support, testing laboratories, transporters, financial
institutions, import agents etc. Geographical concentration of
enterprises taking up similar activities is a prerequisite for existence
of a cluster. Enterprises within clusters share many common features
such as:
-
They have a common resource point for raw
material and other inputs.
-
They share common markets and clients.
-
They have common infrastructure services
and, in many cases, a common cultural identity.
Besides enterprises, clusters also include
support institutions, such as business associations, market aggregators,
financial service providers, public authorities such as local, regional
and national governments, regulatory agencies and academic institutions.
However mere geographical agglomeration of
enterprises cannot ensure high performance of a cluster. There are
instances seen globally where the enterprises in clusters have faced
cut-throat competition from one another. Furthermore, there have been
stagnation and poverty, preventing clusters to reach their full
potential. For taking the collective growth to the desired level, there
has to be strong linkages between the players in the cluster ecosystem.
The diagrams depict the difference between an underperforming cluster
and a healthy cluster, having strong inter linkages.
Clusters: Growth Drivers and Benefits
The clusters in India are repository of
traditional knowledge and skills involving several generations of
people. There exist very unique skill sets, which are intrinsic asset of
the clusters. Some of these clusters get formed and succeed because of
access to pooled labour market of the skilled workers in the region.
Another critical factor which defines growth of a cluster is abundant
availability of raw materials. The role of regional government is also
critical as it often played significant roles in providing seed for
formation and development of the clusters.
The benefits MSME units reap from cluster
formation are multifold. It has the power of reviving a local economy or
pushing an existing system into a higher trajectory of performance.
Economies of scale are developed, reducing cost of production. Greater
synergies are established between enterprises and support institutions.
Development of markets becomes a core activity – export and e- commerce
channels are explored and market intelligence becomes easily accessible.
Due to technology and market interventions in the clusters, often new
products are developed fetching higher value, the sales volume increase,
skill set of the workers are enhanced and accessing finance becomes
easier. Negative impact of manufacturing activities on the environment
can be minimised by combined initiatives like setting up common effluent
treatment plants for wastewater treatment, or a common waste recycling
facility.
Policy Initiatives in India
In independent India, government and policy
makers have taken keen interest in development of clusters. Developing a
cluster is a long-term assignment. There is also need for developing
common resources and when gains are elicited from the established common
resources, there is need for its distribution; all of which require
involvement of a central agency which would have the authority to
perform the function of facilitator – thus state interventions came
naturally to cluster development. There are multiple institutions who
have been playing catalytic role in cluster development in India such as
Department of MSME, Government of India; National Small Industrial
Corporation Limited; Ministry of Textile; Ministry of Science and
Technology. Then there are state governments working in their respective
geographical territories and national support institutions such as SIDBI,
NABARD and State Bank of India.
However, it was only in 2002-03 that cluster
development programmes (CDPs), especially in traditional manufacturing,
gathered noticeable momentum at the national level, with lead taken by
the Ministry of MSME and the introduction of the Small Industries
Cluster Development Programme (SICDP) scheme. The Scheme was later
renamed as Micro and Small Enterprise Cluster Development Programme (MSECDP),
in the year 2006. The Ministry has also launched a cluster development
programme for household (khadi and village industries) enterprises
called the Scheme of Fund for Regeneration of Traditional Industries (SFURTI)
and has also initiated a MSME support scheme called the National
Manufacturing Competitiveness Programme (NMCP).4
Development Alternatives and Cluster
based Work
In its journey of 36 years, significant work
had been undertaken by the Development Alternative (DA) Group in
cluster-based work. DA has been following a value chain development
approach, which comprises of technology upgradation and extension, value
addition-based enterprise development and market access and extension.
It has been working on cluster pertaining to the following sectors:
-
Handicrafts and handlooms: natural dye,
nautical artifacts, bamboo craft
-
Agro processing industry: spice, medicinal
plants, horticulture produce
-
Green building materials: fly-ash based
building material products
-
Energy enterprise hubs: rural enterprise
zones powered by renewable energy
-
Waste to wealth: handmade paper,
construction and demolition waste
IMEDF, the social enterprise development
vehicle of the Development Alternatives Group, is an empanelled Nodal
Agency under the Scheme for Fund for Regeneration of Traditional
Industries (SFURTI) Programme with the Ministry of MSME. IMEDF as the
Nodal Agency is responsible for identification of clusters, selection of
Implementation Agency (IA), having capacity of ground level development
of the cluster, and appointment of Technical Agency (TA). The effort is
to transform traditional village industry into clusters of excellence.
Cluster based Approach: Future
For sustainable and inclusive economy,
wholistic cluster development approach will be the multiplication
engine. It will be the catalyst for enterprise development and will
provide a conducive ecosystem for their sustenance. The focus will need
to be on unexplored sectors and geographies. For instance, there exist
huge scope of work in agriculture sector as around 72% of India’s
vegetable and fruit produce gets wasted. Farm level aggregation,
sorting, storage, value addition can add millions of rupees in income of
the farmers and pull out many from the grasp of poverty. There will be a
ripple effect, centred around the cluster which will have the potential
of transforming the local and national economy.
■
Poulami Datta
pdatta@devalt.org
References:
1 hhttp://dcmsme.gov.in/clusters/clus/indsme.htm
2 https://www.unido.org/sites/default/files/2014-01/UNIDOs_CLUSTER_APPROACH_0.PDF
3 http://fmc.org.in/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Theme-Paper-International-Conference.pdf
4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cluster_development
Back to Contents |