Social marketing for social change

Social marketing, a new concept, combines the best elements of traditional approaches to social change in an integrated planning and action framework and utilizes advances in communication technology and marketing skills, says Pradeep Kashyap, a development practitioner.


Social change can be viewed as taking two forms : changes that occur spontaneously, that take place in the course of life without deliberate planning or rational human intervention, and changes that are planned and engineered by human beings to achieve specific universal objectives and goals. In democratic societies planned social change is generally brought about by the concerned action of governments. In India, family planning, literacy, health, environment are some examples of major social change campaigns. Hundreds of crores of rupees are being spent year after year on these programmes but, as several evaluation studies have shown, the efforts seem to have accomplished little. In some of the programmes it was found that the appropriate audience was not targeted. In others the reform message was not sufficiently motivating and in some, the populations that were targeted were not given a way to respond constructively. Programmes have also failed because the target adopter group did not perceive a problem, want or need like in the anti-smoking campaign where although smokers may acknowledge that smoking is a health hazard, many do not want to do anything about the risk.

Social change is attempted through technological (condoms in family planning), economic (incentives and subsides), political/ legal (land reform laws) and social marketing approaches.

Social marketing is a new concept and the term was first used in 1971. It combines the best elements of traditional approaches to social change in an integrated planning action framework and utilizes advances in communication technology and marketing skills. The social marketing process consists of analysing the environment immediately surrounding the particular social change campaign; researching the target adopter population; defining the social marketing problem; designing strategies; planning the programme and organising, implementing and controlling and evaluating the effort.

People have many beliefs, some attitudes and few values. Campaigns that do not seek to change deep-rooted attitudes or behaviour are generally easy to carry out as they usually have the limited objective of furnishing new information to people and raising their awareness (the AIDS campaign). Others may seek to persuade a given set of individuals to perform a specific act or practice (immunisation programme). Behaviour campaigns are another set which induce people to change some behaviour for their own well-being (anti-smoking campaign).

Professional social research is the first step in understanding the specific needs, beliefs and attitudes of target adopters and the specific characteristics of the social product literacy, family planning). In a recent study, conducted by IMRB for UNICEF in rural India on drinking water, a question was framed : " If villagers were asked to pay a fixed amount per month towards handpump maintenance, failing which the pump would not be repaired, how much would you be willing to pay?" In response to this question district and block officials had predicted that no one would pay, but on an average two out of three village respondents expressed their willingness to pay a monthly fee ranging from Rs. 4.30 in West Bengal to Rs. 20.40 in Rajasthan. this single finding alone would call for a major revision in the present procedures and structures of drinking water delivery system as well as a redefinition of targets.

Or, take the case of the current Nirodh campaign where scientific research would have revealed that husbands want to satisfy their wives sexually and see the condom as a "barrier" to giving the wife complete sexual satisfaction. Or that many believed that the condom would hurt their wives. the campaign strategy should then have been to educate the wives as much as the husbands that the new variety of Nirodh condoms are extremely thin and well lubricated. Politicians and bureaucrats alike readily sanction substantial funds for development programmes but unfortunately hesitate to earmark even small sums for social research in these programmes.
"Why can’t you sell family planning like you sell soap?" was the innocent plea of a development practitioner at a recent workshop. How right he was ! The moe a social programme resembles a commercial product campaign, the more successful it is likely to be because market segmentation, social product positioning, promotional strategy, cost benefit and other aspects are carefully considered and researched. For example, in the Nirodh campaign the product may be more effectively positioned as ‘ the use of condoms (and not side effect-producing birth control pills to be used by women) is what wives expect of husbands, and loving husbands owe it to their wives to use them’. Or consider the oral Rehyderation Therapy (ORT) which is being promoted through government programmes as ‘ a convenient home-made remedy against diarrhoea, the number one killer of infants in our country ‘. However, a more effective product position would be’ a convenient, easy to follow means that any responsible, loving mother can take recourse to when her child has diarrhoea’.

Social marketing is a new concept and the term was first used in 1971. It combines the best element of traditional approaches to social change in an integrated planning and action framework and utilizes advances in communication technology and marketing skills.


Mass media for communication is inevitable as most social programmes attempt to inform and persuade, within a given period, the largest possible number of target adopters. But it is important to conduct research to decide what communication objectives should be set; what to say in the communication; how to say it, where to place the communication and how to time the communication. It would be unfair to expect government officials alone to find answers to these complex issues without seeking help from communication experts. Mass media oriented communication needs to be supplemented by face-to-face communication so that people can discuss what they see or hear with others. This allows people to process information better and they are more likely to accept change. NGOs utilize this personalised approach very effectively in implementing development programmes in rural areas. But, unfortunately, blissfully ignorant bureaucrats continue to believe that mere posters and hoardings can bring about social tansformation and therefore keep increasing their publicity budgets in the hope that DAVP will do the rest.

A social marketing plan needs to be developed finally, once information on profile of target adopters, their current knowledge, attitudes and practices has been collected and having decided on the media message and strategy. This plan must establish standards for implementing the programme and evaluating its outcomes.

Given the fact that government is involved in bringing about profound social changes in so many development sectors like health, family planning, education, environment and community development by spending thousands of crores of rupees, it is important that we develop effective and efficient programmes. And while planning these programmes government should set specific, measurable and attainable social change objectives so that peformance can be monitored and corrective steps taken as required thereby improving monetary and impact efficiencies of such programmes. Objectives like improving the quality of life in our rural areas or empowering women being currently advocated by government are non-specific and therefore non-measurable. Government should make use of scientific knowledge and technology rather than relying simply on adhoc, intuitive hunches and approaches in delivering development. Social marketing is an effective, modern technique for bringing about planned social change and needs to be integrated into our development efforts.

RECLAIMING WASTE WATER

Earth has massive amounts of water - some 1,400 million cubic kilometers of it - yet the supply of fresh water is limited. About 98% of the water is in the oceans and seas, and most of the rest is locked up as ice. we do with a tiny .027 percent of freshwater from rivers, lakes, springs, and underground aquifers.

Industrial development and population growth over the years have produced water shortages in many parts of the world. Meanwhile, human and industrial wastes are increasingly contaminating this precious resource. For example, the Ganga has been polluted severely, and India has mounted a massive effort to cleanse it.

Most methods used for waste water treatment have been mechanical. They are costly and energy intensive. In the search for alternative technologies that are simple, efficient, and cheap, scientists have demonstrated that aquatic plants, such as the water hyacinth, have great potential for wastewater treatment and reclamation because of their photosynthetic systems.

The biological process works something like this : the plants are grown hydroponicall in a filter made of rocks through which waste water flows. The roots, which are home to large numbers of bacteria and other micro-organisms, extend into the waste water. These microbes feed off the minerals and organic chemicals that pollute the water. While digesting the pollutants, the microbes produce by-products such as sugars and amino acids, which are absorbed by the plant roots as food. The plants, in turn, supply oxygen and nutrients to the micro-organisms for their rapid growth.

This symbiotic relationship allows waste water to be purified by the plant roots, and, moreover, the plants’ abundant new leaves help restore oxygen to the air and also regulate the level of carbon dioxide and other atmospheric gases. The large amount of harvested plant material resulting from the process is a potential source of energy, animal feed, fertilizer, and other valuable products.

In the past few years, a number of cities have installed various versions of this aquatic plant-based technology for purifying their waste-water. for example, San Diego, California, has set up a water treatment plant using water hyacinths and Denham Springs, Louisiana, uses cannas lilies for treating its waste water.

Back to Contents

 

Donation    Home   Contact Us About Us