Evidently, sanitation needs to
be strongly infused with an approach which not only safeguards hygiene
by preventing pollution of water resources but also reenforces the
sustainable use of water.
‘Water and sanitation’ is
recognized worldwide as one of the most critical areas of development
planning and implementation. Yet, clearly, different levels of coverage
have been achieved when the two areas are separately looked at. In the
six decades since Independence, India has witnessed phenomenal
development in supply of drinking water - around 86%. However, this
achievement has been at the cost of groundwater depletion, water logging
and increasing salinity levels affecting large areas of the country. On
the other hand, coverage of improved sanitation has been around 33% and
only 15% of the rural population has access to a ‘functional’ toilet.
Conventional ‘end-of-pipe’
sanitation systems based on water-borne sewerage systems and centralized
treatment facilities are unsustainable. Apart from being capital
intensive, they are prone to breakdowns on account of inadequate
maintenance or unavailability of water. Typical alternatives include the
septic tank or a pit latrine (singe or double pit pour flush types).
Both are water-intensive, needing 10- 121itres of water per usage. These
systems tend to pollute the groundwater - often rendering wells unusable
- where issues like proximity of water sources to toilets, subsurface
strata and high groundwater level are overlooked while meeting the
sanitation targets. Moreover, majority of masons are ignorant about
scientific construction methods of septic tanks and the environment
friendly treatment of sludge is virtually non-existent. All these
problems are far more acute in the developing regions of the world where
polluted water related deaths still take a heavy toll.
Ecosan: The New Paradigm
In 2000, the Bellagio
Principles formed the basis for a new paradigm and approach in
environmental sanitation. Ecological Sanitation, or Ecosan as it is
commonly referred to, calls for environmental security at the household
level, stakeholder participation and integrated water resources
management. The new approach recognizes human excreta and water from
households not as a waste but as a reusable resource. The core
principle, as opposed to the process that is used in practice, is to
close material flow cycles instead of a linear flow of nutrients from
agriculture, via humans to recipient water bodies. Ideally, Ecosan
systems enable an almost complete recovery of all nutrients in human
excrement and their re-use in agriculture. They restore a natural
balance between the quantity of nutrients excreted by a person in one
year and that required to produce food - 7.5 kg nitrate, phosphorous and
potassium to produce 250 kg of grain.
Ecosan Technologies
Diverse technologies can be
used in Ecosan systems, from quite simple lowtech to sophisticated
high-tech solutions. These structures currently range from compost
toilets or urine-diverting dry toilets to water-saving vacuum sewage
systems, possibly with separate collection and subsequent treatment of
urine, faeces and grey water through to membrane technology for material
separation and decontamination. The treatment solutions include
prolonged storage, vermi-composting, sludge dehydration and constructed
wetlands! ponds for grey water. Modular design of Ecosan systems allows
optimal adaptation to the local social, economic, ecological and climate
conditions.
Ecosan ‘Dry’ Toilets
The dry toilet is the most
viable aspect of Ecosan in India. Typically, Ecosan toilet is a twin
chamber toilet, one of which is used for defecation till it fills up,
while the other one is kept sealed. Faeces, urine and wash water are
collected separately by designing the toilet accordingly. Human waste
gets com posted in about 8 months when it is free from any
disease-causing pathogens or bacteria. The wash water and urine, after
dilution, can be used for watering plants near the toilet. Proper design
and use of Ecosan toilets can bring down water requirements to a litre
per day for a family. They can be constructed almost anywhere.
The success of Ecosan has been
demonstrated at both the institutional level and household level in
India. German Technical Cooperation (GTZ ) has been instrumental in
creating the first demonstration of Ecosan toilets in India and in
developing a network of resource organizations for Ecosan design,
implementation and training. Paul Calvert of Eco-solutions has developed
urine diverting dry compost toilets with evaporative plant beds in
Kerala. Society for Community Organization and People’s Education
(SCOPE) constructed 250 Ecosan toilets, at a cost of Rs. 6500 per
toilet, in the coastal areas of tsunami-hit Nagapattinam district.
UNICEF has appointed SCOPE as technical consultant for Ecosan concept of
dissemination and training of masons.
Way Forward
A
number of different stakeholders may be involved in Ecosan projects.
NGOs can be instrumental in information and awareness raising, training
communities in use of eco-sanitation systems and linking them to
financial institutions, municipalities, producers of Ecosan equipment,
etc.. Re-use of recyclates (organic material and nutrients) is an
integral part of the Ecosan approach and may need the involvement of
external agencies for collection, transport, treatment and packaging.
Large-scale application of Ecosan sanitation systems may necessitate the
involvement of financial institutions, such as local or international
banks or donor agencies. Local government institutions could establish a
framework to integrate Ecosan services into local or regional sanitation
programmes.
Making such simple and
sustainable solutions indeed would make the future eco-friendly in the
true sense.