study by Praful Bidwai of Global Information Network, in Asia times
Co.Ltd., April 2007 titled "India’s Bubble Economy booms as poverty
grows" presents a grim picture of the Indian economy. It observes
that in 1990s, India added more than a million individuals to the list
of millionaires. One of them, Azim Premji, emerged as the world’s second
wealthiest man for his share holdings in an Information technology firm.
During the same decade, 56 million more Indian’s sank below the official
poverty line, defined in terms of pure animal-level (Indian not
American) survival and consuming the minimum number of calories
necessary to stay alive. In the era of neo-liberal economics, India’s
GDP growth has averaged six percent. But market capitalisation on the
Bombay Stock Exchange has risen at an unbelievable 100 per cent a year.
Surprised? Welcome to India’s
bubble economy. Under the bubble phenomenon, the dissonance between the
country’s real economy and its financial sector has scaled dizzy
heights. Growth has become more lopsided and unevenly distributed,
always notorious in hierarchical India, it has worsened. Agriculture,
central to people’s survival, has stagnated. And the structure of
industry has become more skewed, with the information technology sector
absorbing huge speculative investment while infrastructure decays. The
term ‘growth’ hides more than it reveals in India. Similarly, the
statistics add to growth negative contributions such as pollution, which
alone is estimated to cost the economy 7 to 10 percent, or more than its
annual growth rate.
As the economy registers an
artificial boom, India’s savings and investment rate decrease by three
percentage points and the government’s profligacy reaches new peaks. The
combined fiscal deficit of the central government and the states now
exceeds nine percent of GDP or the same level as the entire tax revenue
of the central government. Each Indian is indebted through the
government to the extent of 50 percent of his/her annual income. The
government has become increasingly parasitical. Its spending upon itself
exceeds its entire revenue income by 3.6 per cent of GDP which would be
considered wholly unacceptable in most countries. Macro-economically
India is back to the critical situation of 1991, which triggered severe
neo-liberal restructuring. The fiscal deficit then reached an
alarming 8.2 percent of GDP.
Income growth in rural areas
where 70 percent Indians live averaged 3.1 percent in 1980 has sharply
declined to 1.8 percent. Real wages of
rural workers decreased in the previous year by more than two percent.
Infant mortality rates are rising even in states such as Kerala and
Maharashtra which have relatively good social indicators. But luxury
consumption is booming within the upper crust. These contradictory
economic features were further accentuated in the national budget two
weeks earlier
The bubble economy has created
the illusion of wealth and progress, first by concentrating high incomes
in the hands of a small number; and secondly by hyping up the IT sector.
Today, young graduates from management school command salaries as high
as $120,000 a year. Such huge disposable incomes are being spent on
luxury items, consumer goods and cars. Automobile sales have recently
risen at 30 percent plus in a year. Following this class in its
aspirations but with lower incomes are hundreds of thousands of people
with a stake in TV entertainment and telecommunications who too are on a
spending spree lubricated by liberal credit.
India’s information technology
sector has burgeoned into a six billion dollar business which scripts
now account for a third of total market capitalisation. Typically, their
price earning ratio is 200 to 300, about ten times higher than the
average. This can only be premised upon the new economy company’s future
profits growingly steadily at 50 percent a year, an unrealistic
assumption.
For the moment, this
speculation acts like a self fulfilling prophecy. The sub-index of
information technology scripts has risen 40 percent in the past two
weeks while the prices of shares of bricks and mortar or old economy
companies fallen by a similar magnitude. This growth cannot last. Sooner
or later, the bubble will burst. The reality will then dawn on
widespread deprivation, backwardness and persistence of regional and
class disparities in India. Until then, however, the bubble will create
and be inflated by illusions about shortcuts to development which bypass
most people and their basic needs.
People First believes the
only method by which India can be rejuvenated and the partition undone
is by instituting true democracy with empowered local governments as
advocated by Gandhi and practised in the best democracies of the West
such as USA Switzerland, Holland and Scandinavian countries through the
referendum process.