Accountability in
Managing Disasters SK Sharma, people@sdalt.ernet.in |
The
Gujarat earthquake has exposedin stark nakedness the inadequacy of our
institutions in managing disasters. What we totally lack is political,
bureaucratic and professional accountability to the people, and the mechanism to
respond to such situations.
Our centralised democracy, based
on the faulty Westminster system and exploitative colonial institutions, is at
the root of all our problems. We need to urgently institute true democracy in
which local governments control local resources to handle all local matters, as
advocated by Gandhi. People First has prepared such a "Constitution for
Free Bharat (India) 2001" and launched a campaign for instituting
independent commissions at the state level for organising wide public
consultations and local referendums on it. Based on these, a similar commission
at the national level shall refine it, and seek approval by the sovereign people
through referendum held along
with the next national election. (Visit our website: www.peoplefirstindia.org)
Within the present system, some
measures that need to be taken immediately are outlined below.
Local Accountability of Municipal
Officials
The permanent but transferable
municipal bureaucracy has no local accountability. It is usually hand in glove
with unscrupulous developers and politicians involved in illegal and faulty
construction.
Municipal officials should be
locally appointed. Local professionals should be appointed as municipal
commissioners and other departmental heads on contract with the approval of and
impeachable by the local assembly. They will then be professionally accountable
directly to the people.
Regulating of Real Estate
Business
Real estate developers take
deposits from consumers, use the money on other projects, and often delay or do
not built according to desired building standards. There are also frauds in
which builders do not have proper title over land and/or build excessive floor
area.
Such frauds and irregularities
are being perpetrated because of absence of legislation regulating real estate
business, and independent check on safety of structures. The laws in North
America are very stringent. The Singapore laws can suit our needs. Under
Singapore laws, developers can take payment in instalments from consumers but
all such payments and loans taken are required to be kept in separate escrow
accounts for each project. The bank releases money in instalments after getting
the progress and safety of the structure certified by its consulting engineers.
Such a basic law is urgently needed in India.
Architectural and Structural
Engineering Services
A most unfortunate practice for
which the government is responsible is that instead of establishing professional
standards, public agencies often invite quotations and tenders for architectural
and structural engineering services. This leads to mediocre or unscrupulous
architects and engineers who quote low, to get public projects. This encourages
builders to also engage poor architects and incompetent engineers, often with
disastrous consequences.
Based on intense study, a
committee of chief executives of Government of India public sector undertakings
prepared a circular, "SCOPE Management Circular on Management of Building
Projects". Government needs to adopt this circular for all public works and
also direct builders who use citizen’s money to also adhere to it. It can
often be disastrous to engage professional services such as those of doctors,
architects and engineers in contravention of norms of professional practice. The
collapse of a number of multi-storeyed buildings in Ahemdabad clearly
establishes this.
Habitat Engineer
The need of an architect cum
engineer trained in cost effective but safe building design and construction,
small water harvesting structures, etc., for meeting the need of small towns and
villages has long been felt. People First has proposed to the government concept
of a three years degree course of Bachelors in Habitat Studies imparting skills
in architecture and engineering adequate to certify individual buildings up to
three stories on plots not exceeding 500 square meters in area. On completing
this programme and one semester attachment in an approved building centre, the
candidate will be designated Habitat Engineer. After stipulated experience and
possibly continuing education on internet he can appear in professional
examinations to become a fully qualified architect or engineer. Such a study
course needs to be urgently instituted.
Earthquake Resistant Structures
The government should get basic
principles of earthquake resistant structures published on rural websites being
set up in various states. Development Alternatives has promoted such a website:
www.TARAhaat.com managed by small rural entrepreneurs.
Such institutional reforms are
the least that the governments should do forthwith for, in view of serious
depletion of our environment, disasters especially draught and floods will now
be an ongoing assault on the people. We urgently need true democracy based on
our several thousand years democratic ethos symbolised in Ram Rajya, described
by Gandhi as Gram Swaraj.
The author is the Managing Trustee, People First Url: www.peoplefirstindia.org
The Government of India has land acquisition policies for large development projects, but people of India have no clearly defined rehabilitation policies.