Housing Renovation
as Part of a Post Hurricane Response Programme Dr Fernando Martirena , f.martirena@ip.etecsa.cu |
Cuba
is an island located at the Caribbean Sea. The northern coast is systematically
hit by tropical hurricanes in their way to northern regions. These hurricanes
cause severe damages to the population living close to the shore, especially at
the provinces located at the central-western part of the island.
There are some urban settlements
at the north of Santa Clara City, province Villa Clara where the accumulated
damage has significantly affected the housing conditions of the inhabitants. The
municipality Sagua la Grande is among one of the most vulnerable areas.
Since 1997, CIDEM (Centro de
Investigacion de Estructurasy Materiales) as part of the Latin American
network ECOSUR, has been working on projects to mitigate the damage caused to
the housings and other buildings by passing hurricanes such as "Lili"
1996 and "George" (1998). Various European foundations have funded
these projects through Grupo Sofonias, the legal owner of ECOSUR network.
Renovation as a target
Many factors contributed to
declare renovation as the means to improve housing. Among them:
a) The budget available was very
small and the number of potential beneficiaries was very high.
b) The city and surrounding areas
has severe land restraints that discourage new construction to the benefit of
renovation.
c) Renovation work is ideal for
self-constructing strategies, other of the main goals of this project.
d) As a general rule, the
population in Cuba remains very stable with a marked trend to decrease in the
forthcoming years due to aging. Thus the demand for new housing will likely
decrease while renovation gets a higher priority.
e) In ecological terms renovation
is far less aggressive than new construction. Factors like energy consumption
can be significantly cut down to a minimum.
Current state of housing
inventory and perspectives
The hit of hurricane "Lili"
during 1998 through the city Sagua la Grande brought about significant damages.
753 housings completely collapsed while 2259 lost the roof. Some of these
damages were healed by emergency actions but still in 1999 there were 99
housings totally collapsed, 137 partially collapsed and yet 597 with severe
damage in the roof.The passage of the hurricane has
just disclosed the latent problem that exists in the municipality: many of the
existing housings have not been properly renovated and their present condition
is very poor thus making them quite vulnerable to natural disasters such as
hurricanes and floods. The deep economic crisis the country had to undergo
during these years cut down renovation activities, whose results could not
change the existing situation.
The opportunities
Some international funding
agencies provided funds to tackle the existing situation. Several institutions
that somehow had something in common with this came together in a synergistic
approach, each with specific aims:
CIDEM
was interested in scaling up some technologies that had been developed by this
institution in the recent years. These technologies were conceived for the
manufacture of ecomaterials (Building materials economic and ecological) at a
very small scale.
The local government and the
National Housing Institute perceived
this as an opportunity to solve some of the community’s problems with
resources external to the municipal budget without compromising ongoing
programmes. They also provided significant amounts of funding to co-finance this
programme.
The Local Industries Enterprise
(LIE), a local institution that
gathers craftsmen, masons and various sorts of hand labor workers took the
challenge of launching into the manufacture of building materials, an approach
they did not have before. The introduction of LIE provided a breath of fresh air
to the intricate bureaucratic net of procedures that provision of building
materials at municipal level implies.
The strategy of the project
The project set very ambitious
goals clearly oriented to "seek and experiment methods to improve habitat
conditions at the northern region of Villa Clara province in a sustainable way
by using appropriate technologies for the manufacture of building materials,
also a well focused strategy for urban intervention as well as a deep process of
popular participation".
The backbone of the strategy was:
1. Setting up a solid
infrastructure for the manufacture of ecomaterials in the region in a
decentralized way.
2. The workshops were operated by
LIE, a locally based enterprise having enough flexibility to cope with local
market conditions.
3. To establish a clear policy
and strategy for urban intervention in the project by defining different
scenarios where the project should move depending of the size of the needed
actions and the resources available.
Implementation phase
A network of ecomaterials
workshops was organized, aiming at local manufacture of building materials
without depending on external resources. Most of these workshops were operated
by LIE in a very flexible and efficient way. The main building materials
produced were:
w Micro Concrete Roofing tiles (MCR) by using the Cuban brand TEVI2 .
w Lime Pozzolana Binder CP-40, a technology developed at CIDEM for the manufacture and use of this binder3
w Hollow concrete blocks with high Portland cement replacement as the main destinations of the CP-40.
This process started early in 1997 when the first workshop was set in the surroundings of Sagua city. The aim was to set up a state of the art workshop that could serve to demonstrate others the features of the CP-40 technology. The Spanish Agency for Foreign Cooperation basically funded this workshop.
Further on there two other workshops set as part of a second project, know as "Hurricane Lili". The aim of this project was to mitigate the damage cause by this hurricane in the region. Some European Foundations contributed with funds that were channeled into the country by the NGO "Grupo Sofonias". The first workshop was located at LIE facilities in Sagua city while the other was located in the municipality Corralillo, 60 km east of Sagua. This had to be relocated two years later due to problems in operation.
The last workshop was set into operation near to Remedios City, in an abandoned facility to manufacture lime. The condition of the lime kiln was improved and for the first time in many years lime was produced on the basis of firewood as fuel (most of the lime produced in Cuba is based on crude oil as fuel)
As a result of the project, a large infrastructure for the local manufacture of materials was created. There is the potential to manufacture 16,000 m2 of MCR roofing, 48,000 m2 of walling, as well as a total production of CP-40 exceeding 400 tons per year. This infrastructure was built with external funds in the range of USD $100,000 in three years, with a similar local contribution.
The strategy for urban intervention was another interesting result of the project. It consisted of shifting from the existing system for popular renovation of housings, based on centralized control and dependence on resources external to the municipality to a more flexible system where the beneficiary becomes the center of the intervention, since he/she is empowered to solve his/her problems on his/her own.
Local manufacture of building materials allowed availability of affordable materials at the local level. The new players (LIE) started to compete with the well-established producers, mainly large enterprises operated at national level with government subsidies. The LIE faced the challenged by producing locally with advantageous conditions in term of transport, and availability of resources.
The project established good working relations with one of the state banks operating in the region, and a mortgage scheme loan was establish for the benefit of the population affected by the disaster. This gave them the capacity to pay up-front for the purchasing of the building materials needed for the renovation of their housings. The same applied for the renovation tasks that were undertaken at neighborhood level, mainly by self-construction.
The resources were distributed
according to the priorities defined in the strategy for urban intervention. This
allowed the project to benefit more than 350 families, who had the chance to
renovate their housings, and nearly 80 of them applied for mortgage loans. Also,
more than 40 new jobs were created as a result of the implementation of the
project.
Lessons learnt
1. A sustainable popular
renovation programme demands a solid and efficient infrastructure for the
manufacture of building materials, which allows some degree of independence from
external resources.
2. The manufacture of building
materials must be undertaken by local enterprises having a flexible
infrastructure and low fixed costs.
3. Provision of a loan scheme
provides access to resources to a poorer sector of society.
4. A urban intervention focused
on renovation must be preceded by devising a clear strategy for urban
intervention, in order to establish priorities for the use of resources.
5. Ecomaterials represent a
viable alternative to traditional building materials.
6. A proper management of the
project resources allows extending the impact of the project to poorer sectors
of society.
This experience can be
easily replicated in other areas, even in other countries, provided favourable
conditions exist.
The author is the Deputy Director of CIDEM, Cuba. International consultant on building materials and technologies
1 Acevedo Catá,J.: Technology for the manufacture of MCR roofing tiles for roofing in countries having a tropical humid climate. ISPJAE.Cuba, 1995
2 J. Martirena; B. Middendorf; M. Gehrke; H. Budelmann: Use of wastes of the sugar industry as pozzolana in lime pozzolana binders: study of the reaction Cement & Concrete Research Vol 28, No. 11 pp. 1525-1536. November 1998- USA