Children of the Monsoon
:An
Environmental Initiative
Kavita Charanji
Islamabad-Lahore-New
Delhi-Varanasi. This was the itinerary for the panelists of a unique
travelling seminar based on the theme "Promoting Better Environment
through Regional Cooperation." As part of the series of regional
programmes, a half day seminar was held at New Delhi’s India Habitat
Centre on May 19, 1998. The seminar, "New Initiatives and
Partnerships for Environmental Management", was jointly organised by
the United States Information Service (USIS) and Development
Alternatives (DA).
The
seminar, attended by around 80 people, could not have been more
timely. To the concern of environmentalists in the South Asia
region, recent reports have shown that the level of human
development and the state of environment is amongst the lowest in
the world. Though significant improvements have been made in certain
sectors, the problems of increasing poverty, illiteracy, disease,
population, women and child abuse and environmental degradation loom
large. Strife within and between nations is leading to increased
military spending.
Various
government and NGO initiatives have been launched for dealing with
these problems. Major programmes have sought to deal with poverty,
education, health care, afforestation and soil and water
conservation. While remarkable success has been achieved in
individual projects, the overall impact on the region is not
significant.
The
seminar, held in New Delhi, therefore had a clear agenda—to evolve
more sustained and realistic individual or collaborative projects
between two or more countries to address some of the major
environmental problems currently facing the South Asian region. The
key issues for discussion included: how to promote regional
environmental cooperation, the challenges ahead, the strategies that
needed to be adopted, how to maximise the benefits of regional
cooperation, how to access funds and what were the required
institutional support systems.
The
seminar opened with a short speech by Dr Ashok Khosla, President,
Development Alternatives, who outlined some of the major
environmental issues confronting the subcontinent, such as air and
water pollution, deforestation, noise congestion, inadequate
resource management, degradation and urbanisation. Said Dr Khosla: "
The level of cooperation between our countries has lagged, but in
the millennium we have to see the close linkages and common problems
of our countries."
Dr
Khosla’s views were shared by E Ashley Wills, Charge d’ Affaires, US
Embassy, who highlighted the importance given by the embassy to
environmental issues.
The
panelists at the seminar then made their presentations. The first
off the mark was Dr RS Shanthakumar Hopper, Project Leader,
Biovillage Project, MS Swaminathan Research Foundation, Chennai.
Turning the spotlight on some of the problems facing South Asia, Dr
Hopper pointed out that 26 million people in the region lacked
access to rudimentary health facilities; 337 million lacked safe
drinking water. To top it all, he said, South Asia was the most
malnourished region. Children were the worst affected. All this was
because the region had the highest degree of militarisation. Added
Dr Hopper: "We need to change direction from schemes and processes
to combatting poverty head on."
"The
children of the monsoon", an evocative expression to describe the
common heritage of people in the subcontinent, formed the leitmotif
of the conference. The phrase was introduced by Dr Syed Ayub Qutub,
President and Chief Executive of the Pakistan Institute for
Environment – Development Action Research, Islamabad. Dr Qutub said
that a billion and more people were sustained by the monsoon but the
pattern of monsoons were undergoing a dramatic alteration because of
climate change. So far, he said, the governments of South Asia had
exercised a global voice in influencing the United Nations Framework
Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Similarly they had taken a
common stand on the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and the
Convention to Combat Desertification. However, the sharing and
learning at the inter-governmental level had been less than at the
business level. A good case was that of Karachi where the 160 or so
tanneries had incorporated a series of effluent treatment plants for
which the technology had been supplied by Iram Consultants, Kanpur,
India.
The
other speakers at the seminar were Pushkar Bhakta Mathema, Associate
Editor, Gorakhapatra, from Kathmandu, Nepal, Dr Biplab Bhushan Basu,
Director, School of Fundamental Research, Calcutta and Dr Parvaiz
Naim, Programme Director, Environmental Assessment Services,
International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural
Resources, Karachi. The theme of Mathema’s presentation was "The
Role of Media in Promoting Environmental Awareness". In Nepal, he
pointed out, there were regular environmental programmes on TV and
radio, while the traditional media, such as puppet shows, were also
mobilised. Dr Basu cited the Joint Forest Management programme in
India as a successful example of an initiative that had the people’s
sanction. Said Dr Basu: " In the sector of policy planning for
environment and development it is important that some of the major
gains are shared. People need to feel that they are co-partners of
the system." The last speaker was Dr Naim who spoke about
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) in Pakistan and how the
component of public participation was subtly woven into it. He
emphasised the need for greater interaction between NGOs on both
sides of the border.
It is a
tribute to the high level of enthusiasm among the participants that,
even as the seminar neared conclusion, the discussion was still
lively. And a diverse range of voices were heard, whether it was a
government official from the Municipal Corporation of Faridabad, a
World Wide Fund for Nature representative, an academic or NGO. More
such meets could break the myth that seminars are mere tedious and
somnolent gatherings.
q
Dr RS
Shanthakumar Hopper
"My
suggestion was that we should change the nomenclature from
travelling seminar to travelling dialogue in the sense of a higher
degree of partnership between NGOs. However, the broader sector of
government to government dialogue is going to take time.
For me
the dialogue has been a learning experience because we can determine
what our neighbouring countries are doing in terms of environment
conservation and sustainable development. It has also shattered the
myth of the divide between the people of India and Pakistan. I have
found that the bonds could grow between the two countries and we
could have a better relationship with them.
I have
asked the USIS to address crucial issues such as food security,
poverty alleviation and biodiversity which are facing the
subcontinent."
Dr
Parvaiz Naim
"The
first advantage of a travelling seminar is that the participants get
to know each other at a personal level, which helps to remind them
that they are in the same boat. Secondly, NGOs get to know what work
their counterparts in other countries are doing.
It is
reassuring to know that greater interaction can take place through
new information systems such as the e-mail and Internet, but one has
to know who to talk to and the issues that need to be discussed. To
amplify this further, a lot of the information we receive comes to
us from Northern countries. We then need to expend considerable
energy and capital to transform this information/technology to suit
our own needs. An easier option would be to go to a neighbouring
country for these inputs."
Dr Syed Ayub Qutub
"Hopefully such seminars can achieve a few things such as the
exchange of vital information person to person and sow the seeds for
building environmental organisation associations across our
countries. In the sphere of information exchange, far more can be
done. For example, NGOs can build cooperative arrangements and
acquire a regional voice that can stand up for sustainable
development in South Asia. To take a case in point, Development
Alternatives and the Pakistan Institute for Environment –
Development Action Research have talked of independent follow up in
the area of environment education through participatory action."
Back to Contents
|