Introduction
TARAgram Yatra1
is a multi-stakeholder dialogue platform initiated by Development
Alternatives and its partners to deliberate upon issues of
sustainability in the context of green economy2
and develop mitigation and adaptation practices to address climate
change. The 2010 event was organised by The DA Group in partnership
with Green Economy Coalition (GEC), the Ring Alliance of Policy Research
Organisations and the International Institute for Environment and
Development (IIED).
TARAgram Yatra 2010 kicked off
with a curtain raiser event on 17th September 2010 in Delhi. It was
followed by field visits to Bundelkhand and TARAgram Resource Centre at Orchha (18–20 September 2010), where the delegates engaged in discussion
on environment-friendly livelihood solutions and how these can be
applied at scale in the climate change context. An interactive plenary
session was organised in Delhi on 21 September 2010, which was attended
by the representatives of prominent Ministries of Government of India,
policy practitioners, various UN representatives, Foundations, financial
institutions, multilateral – bilateral agencies, national and
International Civil Society Organisations. The TARAgram Yatra
2010 event was one in a series of global multi stakeholder consultation
processes (Green Economy Coalition) leading up to Rio+20. The goal of
these consultations is to capture diversity of thinking and action to
inform national policy debate and enrich global deliberations towards
creation of a Green Economy.
The Climate Change Context
Our world faces two epoch
defining issues - persistent poverty and environmental degradation -
both being the inexorable result of adopting a highly lopsided economic
growth model that depends heavily on exploiting natural resources and
consumption habits that essentially affect the environment adversely.
With rapid industrialisation and improvement in material living
conditions in the developed countries, the system itself has kept
millions in the third world countries deprived of basic necessities of
sustenance. At the same time, about one third of the natural resource
endowments have been degraded. According to the statistics of the
International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), there are now
16,306 species threatened with extinction. The total number of extinct
species has reached 785 and a further 65 are only found in captivity or
in cultivation3. There is a growing
international concern about the economic roots of environmental
destruction. According to the 4th
Assessment Report of the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC),
Global total annual anthropogenic Green House Gas emissions have grown
by 70 per cent between 1970 and 2004, which is a major factor driving
global warming. The Report warns that Africa, small islands and Asian
and African mega-deltas will be "especially affected by climate change".
Prioritising Sectors- Sustainable Livelihoods
in times of Climate Change
The facts clearly point out to
the imminent danger that our planet is poised to face and the greatest
impact of it will be on the vulnerable and the poor. This year’s focus
of TARAgram Yatra, "Towards Green Economies – scalable solutions for
people and our planet", cut right to the heart of contemporary
public dialogue and resonated through every feature of DA’s efforts to
promote and facilitate sustainable human development for the poor and
the underprivileged. On examining the potential for "greening" of the
Indian economy, TARAgram Yatra 2010 prioritised five sectors –
renewable energy, eco-construction, sustainable agriculture, waste
management, and water management – where investments towards greening
may be directed.
It is a matter of concern that
while emissions from energy generation in India are projected to
increase, the poor in India do not even have the means to basic energy
consumption. Renewable Energy, which can provide for 35 per cent
of India’s electricity demand by 20304,
has the potential of filling in gaps of power deficit, creating green
jobs and reducing carbon emissions.
Construction is another sector
which uses great quantity of embodied energy5
in the form of materials that are used. Eco-construction is a
concept that promotes economical use of construction materials such as
cement and steel, which are excessively energy and resource intensive,
while exploring alternative material sources, such as waste from
industries and bio-systems, debris mining, etc. The Yatra considered
eco-construction as an effective way to mitigate pressure on finite
natural resources and reduce energy consumption.
In our country, almost 52 per
cent of the workforce is dependent on agriculture and allied activities.
The major threats to agriculture are depletion of natural resources and
land quality, climate variability leading to crop failures, along with
high input6 prices and an uncertain
sale market for agricultural produce. For Sustainable Agriculture,
the Yatra laid emphasis on measures, such as reviving traditional crop
varieties by setting up more seed banks, less usage of artificial
fertilizers, while relying more on natural manure and planning
appropriate crop cycles, regulations for middlemen7
to increase the selling capacity and autonomy of farmers in choosing
plant and crop varieties, providing Research and development to
strengthen the small and marginal farmer’s knowledge for improved
practices and mainstreaming efficient irrigation practices.
The Yatra considered Waste
Management as a sector, which had tremendous wealth generation
potential,8 especially for small
community groups and entrepreneurs. Prominence was given to research and
development to develop technologies for waste utilization, both at
large-scale and small-scale collection and management. It was felt that
the biggest challenges lay in integrating the different scales of
operation and in establishing bench-marks for ‘green waste management’,
while enforcing waste disposal and resource utilisation regulations at
all levels of the value chain.
The Yatra was of the view that
Water Management needs to be understood and addressed in its
various facets of planning, budgeting, harvesting, optimal use,
recycling and regeneration. For an efficient water management framework,
the Yatra proposed to invoke the Dublin Principles in water management,
which argue for a participatory approach in water management, gender
sensitivity to promote women participation in managing and functioning
of water management and distribution bodies and assessment of the
economic value of water. It was argued that a participatory approach
will bring about a mechanism of responsible use of water, which can be
sustained over a long period of time, while women participation will
allow the use of inherent qualities that women have regarding
managing/using water, because water as a commodity influences the lives
of women the most9.
Conclusion
Driving our growth path towards
reaping the adaptation and mitigation co-benefits to protect environment
in the face of climate change, while addressing livelihood concerns is a
complex process, which necessarily has to adopt participatory approach
involving all the stakeholders at various levels (local, national as
well as global). The Declaration adopted in TARAgram Yatra 2010
recognised that green growth would need to strengthen people’s
institutions, empower citizens, secure eco-system services, enhance
purchasing power, reduce carbon foot prints, reverse the loss of
biodiversity and revive the health of our eco-systems at a large scale.
Such policies and mechanisms for scaling up of solutions to climate
change impact and a transformation to a green economy require coherent
overall vision, agreement on outcomes from all stakeholders, political
will and a critical mass of public opinion to enable transformation at
the scale required. The outcome of the TARAgram Yatra 2010 is a small,
but significant step forwards an enriched policy engagement with
governments and the private sector for creating a better future for all
of us.
q
For further information please
visit www.taragramyatra.org
Sourindra Mohan Ghosh
sghosh@devalt.org
Rizwan-Uz-Zaman
ruzaman@devalt.org
Footnotes
1 Yatra means a journey or pilgrimage that one takes with friends and
colleagues to attain higher goals.
2 A Green Economy as a system produces and ensures equitable
distribution of goods and services, including ecological goods and
services, while simultaneously maintaining ecological balance and
replenishing natural capital.
3 IUCN Press Release, 2007.
4 Energy [R]evolution: A Sustainable India Energy Outlook, Report,
Greenpeace International.
5 Embodied energy in a product is defined as the energy that was used in
the work to make that product, bring it to market and dispose it off.
6 Seeds, fertiliser, power and water for
irrigation etc.
7 Those who control the market where farmers sell their produce, as well
as those who control the inputs like seed, and fertiliser markets.
8 Flyash brick is an excellent example of this. Flyash, a waste product
from thermal power plants, is mixed with two other ingredients: lime,
which is a by - product of the acetylene industry and gypsum from
chemical plants. Flyash bricks do not require sintering (baking)
process, meaning no energy is required.
9 It is the women who spend long hours in collecting and carrying water
over long distances for domestic and other purposes, particularly in
rural areas.